Desserts

Crème Brûlée 9.5

Vanilla Bean Custard, Caramelized Sugar topping

N.Y. Style Cheese Cake 9.5

Graham Cracker Crust, Raspberry Coulis

Nutella Crepe 10.5

Vanilla Cream Cheese filling, Roasted Hazelnuts, Sea Salt and Vanilla ice cream

Peanut Butter Trifle 11.5

Peanut Butter Mousse layered in a Mason Jar with Chocolate Cake and Feuilletine

Molten Chocolate Cake 12.5

Flourless Chocolate Cake, Crème Anglaise, Vanilla Bean ice cream

Apple Cobbler 12.5

Streusel Topping, Vanilla Ice Cream, Caramel Sauce, Cookie Crust

Old Fashioned Banana Cream Pie 12.5

Vanilla Wafer Crust, Whipped Cream

Bourbon Spiked Pecan Pie 12.5

Chocolate Sauce, Vanilla Ice Cream

Just a Taste

5.5

Just for her

Strawberry Shortcake

Just for him

Chocolate Marshmallow Smore

Just for me

Red Velvet

Just for you

Coconut Crème Brûlée

Put ‘em all together

18.5

After Dinner Drinks

9.5 • Topped with Fresh Whipped Cream

Juan Valdez

Patron XO Tequila

Decadent

Kahlua, Bailey’s & Frangelico

Caribbean

Malibu, Meyers, Amaretto

Dark Monk

Frangelico, Hershey Syrup

Fightin’ Irish

Bushmill’s Black

Italian

Tia Maria or Strega

Perfekte Koffie

Van Gogh Double

Espresso Vodka

Ask your server for our extensive list of after drinks from all over the world! Pastry Chef Alison Santoro

“Rothmann's truly is a gem & incredibly delicious! If you want to enjoy one of the best Sunday brunch experiences, then you have come to the right place. You must try the chilled lobster & shrimp. The creamed spinach was seriously the best I've ever had! The create your own omelette was delightful & OMG the chocolate mousse was so scrumptious that I wish I had started with that first since I barely had any room left! The fruit & cheese selection was divine & the service was impeccable. Although slightly pricey, it was most assuredly worth every penny! Make sure you go hungry!”- Lesley O.     
“This steakhouse is ran like a well-oiled machine. The place is beautiful and it has some great food. If you like steak they have the best you can buy. If you do not prefer a good chop, try out any of their other selections on the menu. I have been here on multiple occasions and I have always enjoyed myself. The sushi is great for an appetizer and the whiskey sugar sirloin is an awesome main course. I definitely recommend this steakhouse for a great night out.”- Michael C.     
“As good as it gets on Long Island - Rothmann's ranks for me as my #1 favorite steakhouse restaurant on Long Island. The restaurant provides a winning combination of really great food, excellent table and valet service, and an overall dinning atmosphere of excellent ambiance which makes for a truly classy establishment.”- John H.     
“The best. The absolute best. Service is the royal treatment. Presentation is phenomenal. Mushrooms are out of this world. Obviously the steaks melt in your mouth. Mashed potatoes, superb.”- Mike A.     
“Dined at Rothmann's Steakhouse a couple of weeks ago for my brother's birthday. Our evening was nothing short of lovely. The food, cocktails and atmosphere was perfect! Rothmann's is my go to restaurant for a special night out.”- Chloe L.     
“I went to Rothmanns for a birthday dinner two weeks ago. I have dined there a number of times in the past and it is always outstanding. Being from NYC I enjoy the typical "bar scene" and Rothmanns was lively! I have been to many great Steak Houses both on Long Island and in New York City and I absolutely loved Rothmann's. My boyfriend ordered the New York Strip as his entree and I had sushi. Both were delicious. Can't wait to come back.”- Gabriella B.     